Markets
BTC $56,195 -8.74% ETH $1,571 -9.04% BNB $517 -8.93% XRP $0.8799 -8.71% SOL $66.06 -8.42% LINK $8.14 -7.40% BTC $56,195 -8.74% ETH $1,571 -9.04% BNB $517 -8.93% XRP $0.8799 -8.71% SOL $66.06 -8.42% LINK $8.14 -7.40% TOTAL $1.97T BTC.D 57.2%

Crypto Regulation

Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case, Finding No Fraud

The first criminal prosecution built on a maximal extractable value exploit has collapsed on the element of reliance, not on what the brothers did.

A federal judge has cleared two MIT-educated brothers over the roughly $25 million they extracted from Ethereum trading bots in April 2023, ending the US government’s first criminal prosecution built on a maximal extractable value exploit.

Judge Jessica Clarke ruled on 16 November that prosecutors failed to establish the material misrepresentation that wire fraud requires. The decision also cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. It follows a mistrial in November 2025, when jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict.

Clarke described Ethereum as a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” a characterisation that captures how hard it is to decide when exploiting a weakness in blockchain infrastructure becomes a crime.

The case centred on bots that watch Ethereum’s public transaction queue, the mempool, for chances to profit by influencing the order in which trades settle. One common strategy, the sandwich attack, spots a large pending purchase, buys the same asset ahead of it and sells once the original order has moved the price.

Prosecutors said the brothers planted eight bait transactions in April 2023 to draw those strategies in. When their validator was selected to produce a block, they exploited a weakness in the Ultrasound relay. The validator signed a block header with two fields set to zero, describing a block that could not be valid, and the relay passed the header on without verifying those fields, disclosing the transactions inside.

The brothers then built their own block, preserving the bots’ purchases but replacing the bait trades with sales that pushed prices lower. The targeted bots lost about $25 million in 12 seconds, while the brothers’ validator took a penalty of roughly 1 ETH.

The contested element was reliance. Clarke rejected the argument that placing a transaction in the public mempool creates an implicit agreement about how it will be processed, and found that the falsified header fields could not amount to fraud because the relay never checked them and so was never influenced by them.

She acknowledged that the brothers concealed their intentions and may have violated the spirit of the relay software’s design, but held that conduct which is improper or objectionable does not by itself constitute wire fraud. The ruling leaves the technical exploit untouched as a description of events and places the criminal exposure of MEV strategies on narrower ground.

Share this article

Viber uses viber://forward?text= when the app is installed.