Markets
BTC $56,258 -8.50% ETH $1,563 -9.33% BNB $514 -9.36% XRP $0.8743 -8.98% SOL $65.96 -8.25% LINK $8.12 -7.24% BTC $56,258 -8.50% ETH $1,563 -9.33% BNB $514 -9.36% XRP $0.8743 -8.98% SOL $65.96 -8.25% LINK $8.12 -7.24% TOTAL $1.97T BTC.D 57.3%

Altcoins

Tether Rejects S&P’s Weakest Stability Score as Risk Assets Reach 28% of USDT

The agency held USDT at the bottom of its five-point scale over reserve composition and transparency, and the issuer blamed the methodology.

S&P Global Ratings has kept its stability assessment for tether at 5, the weakest score on a five-point scale, and Tether has answered by arguing that the fault lies in the framework rather than the reserves.

The assessment, published on 18 November, is unchanged from November 2025, when the agency first cut USDT to the bottom of the scale. Its central concern is composition: higher-risk holdings including bitcoin, gold, public equities, secured loans and corporate bonds made up about 28% of USDT in circulation at 30 September, up from 24% a year earlier. A sharp fall across several of those assets at once could leave the token undercollateralised, S&P warned.

The agency also questioned the regime Tether operates under in El Salvador, where it moved in January 2025. The national digital assets commission requires 70% of reserves in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days, but S&P calls that definition broad enough to admit bitcoin, gold and loans. It noted there is no requirement to segregate reserve assets from the issuer’s other holdings, a safeguard US and European regulators generally expect, and said the absence of public information on segregation leaves it unable to judge how well reserves are shielded from corporate risk.

Tether’s own numbers look comfortable by comparison. Its 30 September reserve report, attested by BDO, showed about $191.5 billion of assets against $183.5 billion of liabilities, an excess of roughly $7.95 billion. In August 2026 KPMG issued an unqualified opinion on the company’s 2025 accounts, which Tether described as its first full independent audit. S&P acknowledged the audit but said neither the statements nor the auditor’s report have been published, limiting what it can verify. It also flagged that reserve reports do not name the custodians holding the assets.

S&P said it found additional weaknesses in its review but did not lower the score because 5 is already the floor.

Tether’s response was that the problem is the rating methodology, not the portfolio, and it invoked The Big Short — the film about the 2008 mortgage collapse — to argue that traditional finance’s own risk assessments have a poor record.

Both sides are describing the same trade-off. USDT has grown by holding assets that earn a return, and those assets carry mark-to-market risk a pure Treasury book would not. The dispute is over how much of that risk belongs in a token that functions as dollar infrastructure for trading venues and, increasingly, for payments.

Share this article

Viber uses viber://forward?text= when the app is installed.