A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, ending a prosecution the government itself described as the first of its kind. Judge Jessica Clarke granted the brothers’ motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday, closing the case without a retrial.
The charges grew out of April 2023. The brothers placed bait transactions designed to lure specific sandwich bots, then exploited a bug in a relay’s code to see the bots’ bundled trades before committing a block. They swapped the bait for trades that sold the tokens instead, leaving the bots with about $25 million in losses in roughly twelve seconds. Both were arrested in May 2024; a jury deadlocked in November 2025 and the judge declared a mistrial.
Clarke’s reasoning turned on the elements of wire fraud rather than on the conduct itself. “The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” she wrote. Prosecutors had to show a material misrepresentation, and none of their theories established one. Ethereum, she noted, is a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.” The scheme may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost, the software that lets validators outsource block building to specialised relays, but that was not fraud. The money laundering count fell with the fraud counts because it depended on their proceeds.
A footnote may prove as consequential as the holding. Clarke wrote that the prosecution “raises serious due process concerns,” though she declined to rule on the question once the acquittal disposed of the case.
For market structure, the ruling draws a line between exploiting a protocol and deceiving a person. The brothers did not compromise a wallet or phish a key; they read information a relay made visible to someone in their position and traded on it. A court has now held that reading it, and the trading that followed, does not meet the threshold for wire fraud on the theories the government brought.
That leaves the sandwich bots as the losers and raises the question of who protects them. Their business is extracting value from other users’ pending transactions, which makes them the least sympathetic victims in the ecosystem and an awkward basis for a landmark prosecution. The decision does not legalise the conduct so much as confirm that criminal law, built around misrepresentation, fits adversarial trading in a system without terms of service poorly.
It also sharpens the case for protocol-level defences. If the remedy for value extraction is not prosecution, it is design: encrypted mempools, order-flow auctions with enforceable rules, and relays whose code does not leak bundled trades to a builder who asks for them in the right way. The relay bug at the centre of this case was a code defect, and code defects are fixed by code.
The broader signal is about enforcement appetite. A case that took three years, a trial and a mistrial to end in acquittal is a costly way to establish that a novel strategy was not a crime, and prosecutors now have a documented answer when the next one arrives. Whether that answer deters future cases or merely redirects them toward defendants who did misrepresent something is the open question.