Markets
BTC $56,258 -8.50% ETH $1,563 -9.33% BNB $514 -9.36% XRP $0.8743 -8.98% SOL $65.96 -8.25% LINK $8.12 -7.24% BTC $56,258 -8.50% ETH $1,563 -9.33% BNB $514 -9.36% XRP $0.8743 -8.98% SOL $65.96 -8.25% LINK $8.12 -7.24% TOTAL $1.97T BTC.D 57.3%

DeFi & Web3

Cardano Delegates Reject 22 Million ADA Copper Reserve Proposal

Delegates voted 2.86 billion ADA to 20 million against a tokenised copper scheme that would have paid Toto Finance about 3.4 million ADA.

Cardano’s delegated representatives rejected a proposal to spend 22 million ADA from the treasury on a “Strategic Copper Reserve,” closing a vote on November 15 with 2.86 billion ADA opposed and 20.02 million in favour.

The proposal came from Toto Finance, a company led by Monty Metzger, and was submitted on October 15. It would have used 14.72 million ADA to buy copper stored in a warehouse near New Orleans, issuing one CuTT token per pound of metal, with the position to be sold in 18 to 24 months. At $0.152 per ADA the request is now worth about $3.3 million, against the $5 million figure used when it was drafted.

DRep John MacPherson explained his no vote by pointing at the double exposure: the proposal asks the treasury “to take on both the copper price and the ada price,” and Toto Finance would collect “up to about 3.4M ada in fees.” He added that the plan is “more honest about its risks than most,” a qualified endorsement that did not survive the fee or the concentration.

The Cardano Foundation, which votes as a DRep, announced its opposition in October. “We recognize the opportunity in real-world asset tokenization; however, this proposal places 22,000,000 ada under the recipient’s sole control to fund a fee-heavy concentrated commodity position whose safeguards are not yet in place,” it wrote.

Three of the seven Constitutional Committee members voted no; the other four did not vote. The decisive margin sat with stake-weighted DReps, where opposition outweighed support by more than 140 to one.

The vote tests what a treasury is for. Buying copper with protocol funds would have placed a commodity position on the balance sheet of every ADA holder, and the 3.4 million ADA fee amounts to roughly 15% of the ask — charged in a token that has fallen by more than 80% from its cycle high.

Real-world asset tokenisation remains the stated interest on all sides; the objection was to structure, not category. A smaller request with custody arrangements, an auditor and a fee tied to performance would meet a different reception, though nothing in the vote commits the treasury to one.

Share this article

Viber uses viber://forward?text= when the app is installed.