Kalshi’s fight with New York Attorney General Letitia James reaches a Manhattan state courtroom on Monday, when Justice Melissa Crane is asked to impose a temporary restraining order on the prediction-market exchange while the underlying lawsuit proceeds. The hearing is set for 11:30 a.m. Eastern.
The request turns on a phrase. James wants an order barring Kalshi’s unlicensed gambling operation within or from New York, and blocking it from serving state residents. It would cover contracts tied to sports, culture, elections and other events, bar users under 21 and stop advertising on college campuses. Kalshi argues that the words from New York are the dangerous part, because the company is headquartered in the state and a limit on its New York operations could reach every customer it has.
That reading, Kalshi says, could force open positions to be liquidated and would conflict with an August order from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission directing it to keep operating as a registered exchange. James’ office rejects the interpretation. In a Friday filing, the state said the order would leave lawful futures and swaps available and urged Crane to disregard the CFTC’s August directive, pointing to a November ruling that criticised the agency’s intervention in a separate prediction-market case.
The procedural run-up has gone badly for the federal side. On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick sent James’ enforcement case back to state court, rejecting Kalshi’s argument that it belonged in federal court. On Friday, U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield refused the CFTC’s renewed bid to stop the state case, finding the agency had not shown a likelihood of success on its preemption argument.
The CFTC and the Justice Department sued New York in April, arguing that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the commission exclusive authority over event contracts listed on federally registered exchanges. Three federal appeals courts have sided with states in related disputes and one has backed Kalshi, a split that makes a Supreme Court appeal plausible whichever way the circuits settle.
Crane is not being asked to decide whether Kalshi’s contracts are gambling or regulated derivatives. She is being asked how far a state court order can reach, and what Kalshi must change while litigation continues. The answer matters beyond New York. If from New York is read broadly, a single state regulator can effectively set terms for a nationally registered venue. If it is read narrowly, the state’s leverage is confined to residents and activity inside its borders, and the larger question of who regulates event contracts stays with the appeals courts.
Kalshi has framed the case as existential for its U.S. business, warning that customers outside New York would be caught by an order aimed at the state. James has framed it as consumer protection against an unlicensed gambling operator, and her office says a nationwide shutdown is not the goal. Monday’s ruling will not resolve either claim, but the wording Crane chooses will show how much a state can do to a federally supervised exchange before the higher courts speak, and it will set the terms of the fight for the rest of the case.