Nine Democratic senators have asked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to withdraw or freeze an interpretation that gives prediction markets 30 days to drop state-by-state geographic restrictions, arguing it collides with court orders already in force.
The letter was sent to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on Monday, November 16, and led by California Senator Adam Schiff. It was signed by every senator from California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington — all Democrats — along with Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the ranking member on the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the agency. The senators asked for a response confirming the agency is preserving records by November 23, covering material back to January 1, 2025.
The interpretation, issued November 5, told exchanges they had 30 days to remove geographic limits or explain why they could not, on the grounds that such restrictions breach the agency’s requirement of impartial access to its markets.
The senators counter that courts have ordered platforms to stop offering certain contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and on the land of two California tribes, and have required geofencing to enforce those rulings. They wrote that the Commission appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of those orders during active litigation.
Timing is central to their complaint. The interpretation arrived just hours after a federal court in California ordered Kalshi to geofence tribal land in a suit brought by the tribes, which the senators said raises concerns that the agency may be coordinating with platforms currently in litigation. At a minimum they want the CFTC to state that geoblocks imposed by court order, adopted under federal Indian gaming law or tribal-state compacts, or added voluntarily by an exchange do not violate its rule.
The letter lands while the agency is reported to be examining both major platforms. Politico reported Monday that the CFTC has separate investigations open into Kalshi and Polymarket. The Kalshi probe concerns whether the company properly notified the agency about dozens of new products, and the regulator recently warned it of potential charges that could end in a settlement; Kalshi has called the warning a procedural matter involving a handful of contracts, many not live. The Polymarket investigation is broader and partly concerns a 2022 settlement that required the company to close its platform to US users.
CFTC spokesperson Zach Fulton told Politico that the agency’s enforcement work knows no bounds and that it will pursue misconduct wherever it occurs.