The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to review Custodia Bank’s challenge to the Federal Reserve’s refusal to grant it a master account, ending the Wyoming institution’s six-year effort to connect directly to the central bank’s payment rails. The case, Custodia Bank v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, appears as “certiorari denied” on the Court’s Monday order list.
A master account is a bank’s account at a regional Federal Reserve Bank and the entry point to Fedwire and the Fed’s other payment services. Without one, a state-chartered bank must route dollar movements through a correspondent institution, which adds a layer of cost and counterparty exposure to every transaction it settles.
Custodia is a Wyoming special purpose depository institution, a charter that forbids lending and requires customer dollar deposits to be held in fully reserved liquid assets. After receiving that charter it applied for a master account at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City in October 2020. In January 2021 the reserve bank confirmed the firm was legally eligible and told it there were “no showstoppers.” Custodia applied for Fed membership in August 2021. Both requests then sat pending.
In August 2022 the Board of Governors published guidelines for evaluating master-account applications. Firms that are neither federally insured nor supervised by a federal banking agency were placed in a “Tier 3” group that “generally receive[s] the strictest level of review.” Custodia fell into that bucket. On January 27, 2023, Kansas City denied the account, citing an “unprecedented” business model “narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities” and concluding the risks were “highly likely” to be “inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices.” The Board denied membership the same day.
Custodia had already sued in June 2022 over the delay. In March 2024 a federal judge in Wyoming held that the Federal Reserve Act gives reserve banks discretion to grant or deny master accounts, dismissed the Administrative Procedure Act claim for lack of final agency action, and granted Kansas City summary judgment. A Tenth Circuit panel affirmed 2-1 in October 2025. Judge David Ebel, joined by Judge Veronica Rossman, read Section 342’s statement that a reserve bank “may receive” deposits as discretionary, and treated the Monetary Control Act’s promise that Fed services “shall be available” to nonmember banks as a pricing rule rather than a right to an account. Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented: “We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall.”
The practical effect is that the discretion the Tenth Circuit identified now stands as settled law in that circuit, and no court has ordered the Fed to open its payment system to a crypto-focused bank. Institutions weighing a similar charter route have no judicial precedent to point to when arguing that eligibility creates an entitlement.
Custodia’s fight produced one of the few public records of how the Fed evaluates novel charters, including the 2022 tiering framework that put uninsured, non-federally supervised applicants at the back of the queue. That framework, not the Supreme Court’s order, is now the operative constraint on crypto banks seeking direct access.