A stablecoin is designed to hold a $1 value. That design says nothing about what happens to the dollar behind it if the company issuing the token becomes insolvent. Holdings are not covered by government deposit insurance, and unlike a bank account they do not automatically become a claim on an insurance fund.
Insolvency does not usually mean the money disappears. It means redemptions may be suspended while a court or regulator works out how remaining assets are distributed, and the outcome depends on three things: what the reserves actually contain, whether those reserves are legally ring-fenced from the issuer’s other creditors, and whether the holder has an enforceable claim to them.
A simple illustration shows the range. An issuer with $1 billion of tokens outstanding and $900 million of recoverable reserves would return roughly $0.90 per token if the assets were split proportionally, before costs and any later recoveries. That is arithmetic, not a forecast for any issuer, but it shows why the size of the reserve and the strength of the legal claim are separate questions.
The two largest issuers structure those claims differently. Circle says USDC is backed by dollar-denominated assets held separately from its corporate funds, and its October 2026 terms state that direct redemption through Circle generally requires an eligible Circle Mint account. Circle’s European white paper says reserves are safeguarded against claims from the issuer’s other creditors, including during insolvency, a protection that flows from the EU’s MiCA framework.
Tether’s terms describe USDT redemption as a contractual right available to verified customers, subject to eligibility requirements, minimum amounts and fees. They do not promise government insurance, and they do not promise unconditional redemption to every holder who bought on a secondary market.
US law is moving toward a statutory answer. The GENIUS Act, signed in July 2025, creates bankruptcy protections for holders of eligible payment stablecoins, giving them priority over other creditors with respect to required reserves. Its general effective date is January 2027 unless implementing regulations bring parts of it forward sooner, which means the protections should not be assumed to apply to every token today.
One more layer sits between the holder and the issuer. A stablecoin bought on an exchange and left there is also a claim on that exchange, and an exchange failure raises custody questions that have nothing to do with the issuer’s reserves.