Markets
BTC $56,292 -8.48% ETH $1,567 -9.10% BNB $517 -8.91% XRP $0.8775 -8.78% SOL $66.11 -8.13% LINK $8.14 -7.11% BTC $56,292 -8.48% ETH $1,567 -9.10% BNB $517 -8.91% XRP $0.8775 -8.78% SOL $66.11 -8.13% LINK $8.14 -7.11% TOTAL $1.97T BTC.D 57.3%

Crypto Regulation

Witt: Clarity Act Died on Ethics, and the Rules Will Now Come From Agencies

Trump's former crypto adviser says the bill was lost to the clock and to a fight over the president's own digital asset ventures.

The Senate’s failure to pass the Clarity Act was “a failure of American leadership,” according to Patrick Witt, until last month the executive director of the President’s Council of Advisers for Digital Assets and the official who led the White House push for the bill.

“It was extremely disappointing,” Witt said in an on-stage interview at Solana’s Breakpoint conference in London. “I was knee deep in Clarity. I lived it for a year plus negotiating that bill,” he added, saying it “would have been incredibly impactful.” The legislation, which would have set a framework for regulating crypto markets, failed a key procedural vote in the Senate in September.

His account of the collapse is less about substance than about arithmetic. “We ultimately lost against the clock,” he said. “The policy was good. We resolved pretty much all of the policy differences.” With the midterms approaching, he argued, “the political issue of ethics really consumed everything else.”

Democrats had raised concerns about the Trump family’s crypto ventures, and Witt acknowledged that the president’s involvement was “arguably the issue.” He said Trump had agreed to two ethics provisions, the second of which would have barred federal officials, including the president, from issuing or sponsoring digital assets, forced divestment or a blind trust, and let state attorneys general enforce violations. “There’s no precedent for those kinds of things in American law,” he said.

He contrasted the outcome with the GENIUS stablecoin bill, which lost an initial procedural vote in 2025 but recovered because it came early in Trump’s term. With Clarity, “we knew that we were going to get one shot at it, and unfortunately we just came up short.”

Looking forward, Witt put the odds of a comprehensive replacement low. “I would expect that market structure in the United States is going to be less written on Capitol Hill and more written in the Federal Register, which is where the agencies do their rulemakings and issue their guidance.” Pieces of the bill could still travel inside larger packages, and lawmakers could grant targeted powers such as CFTC authority over spot crypto markets.

He said regulators already have “ample authority” and that the administration had to “hold them back a little bit” while the bill played out. The SEC and CFTC have since advanced their own crypto rules, though House Financial Services Chairman French Hill has said those efforts fall short of what legislation would have achieved. Chairs Paul Atkins and Michael Selig, Witt said, “are committed to moving markets on chain.”

Democrats won both chambers this month and are reportedly preparing a broader market structure bill of their own. Witt said he is “not bearish on the industry overall,” since the regulators and the president remain in place, and framed the fight as generational rather than purely partisan: “Capital is going to go where it’s treated best.”

Share this article

Viber uses viber://forward?text= when the app is installed.